From Bryan Hoch:
When Aaron Judge surveys the Yankees’ lineup, he sees each spot occupied by someone trying to be a hero. It’s an admirable quality, but it also might not necessarily be what they need right now.
The Yankees absorbed their fifth consecutive defeat on Sunday, a 5-4 loss to the Rays at Tropicana Field that completed a three-game sweep. As they head back to the Bronx for a week-long homestand, the captain said he’d like to see their hitters get back to basics.
“We need to simplify some things at the plate,” Judge said. “We’re trying to hit every single pitch we see up there and getting ourselves in some bad counts and bad situations. As a group, if we simplify our approach a little bit, hunt the pitch that we’re looking for and pass the baton, I think we’ll be in a better spot.”
He’s right, of course, but that’s just a fucking baseball slump in a nutshell, right? Once you are stuck in a slump, you start pressing, and then things begin to spiral. We see it with Judge himself, where he starts to expand the zone when he gets frustrated. We have seen it MANY times with Stanton.
The problem with this team isn’t even their shitty hitters on the bottom of the lineup, but it is that their main guys in the middle of the lineup are all shitting the bed during this streak, outside of Ben Rice. If Ben Rice and, say, Giancarlo Stanton were hot this past week, the Yankees would EASILY have won 2 of the 5 games they just lost.
If Ben Rice and Cody Bellinger were hot, same thing. If Ben Rice and Aaron Judge were hot, same thing.
But only Ben Rice was hot this past week, and that’s not enough. THEN you need contributions from the rest of the order, and they sure as fuck were not getting them.
And yet, even with that in mind, MULTIPLE times the Yankees had the tying run in scoring position in the ninth inning (or the go-ahead run in scoring position in the ninth inning) and the Yankees EVERY FUCKING TIME chose to go with a shittier hitter than the readily available Paul Goldschmidt, with Boone choosing to go to Randall Grichuk twice, Ryan McMahon twice, and JC fucking Escarra once (the Escarra one will be one for the ages. “Where were you when Aaron Boone decided to call on JC fucking Escarra to pinch hit with the game on the line in the bottom of the ninth inning?”).
The Yankees have just lost five straight games, FOUR OF THEM by a single run, and in NOT A SINGLE ONE OF THEM did Paul Goldschmidt get to pinch hit.
I want to make things clear. I know that Goldschmidt, who only won the MOST VALUABLE PLAYER AWARD four years ago, is not the hitter he once was. There is a VERY good chance that he would have been retired in every single one of the instances that I mentioned. But that’s fucking baseball for you. You take your best licks, and if you lose, you lose. But when you DON’T use your best guys and lose, then you are always going to think, “What if I WASN’T such a fucking moron and used Paul Goldschmidt instead of JC fucking Escarra?”
Here, with the tying run on second base and two outs, the Rays opted to walk Austin Wells to face Ryan McMahon, and Boone decided to NOT pinch hit Goldschmidt, even though, had Goldy tied the game and it went to extras, Rosario could have moved to third, Judge moved to right field, and they would just lose the DH (and since that would be Goldy’s spot, it wouldn’t be up for a while anyways). It was the obvious move, but Boone apparently just hates Goldschmidt, and thinks he can only hit lefties (despite hitting a three-run home run off of a good righty for the Mariners).
McMahon came up, and promptly grounded out to end the game (a game that was only ever in doubt because Kevin Cash oddly pulled a dominant Drew Rasmussen after six even though the Tampa Bay bullpen fucking SUCKS. Think about this – they gave up four runs to a terrible Yankee offense. Gross).
Now, as I have noted, these negative results are obviously unlikely to continue. You can think McMahon is only an 80 OPS+ hitter, but he is currently a 14 OPS+ hitter. That shit ain’t right.
Similarly, you can think Randall Grichuk is washed, and maybe he is, but he’s HITLESS IN HIS FIRST THIRTEEN AT-BATS. He can’t possibly be THAT washed. JC Escarra, similarly, has not gotten a hit yet. That’s NOT normal.
So I’ll be frank, I knew they were fucked in this game because of Drew Rasmussen, who owns them when they’re doing WELL, let alone a slump, but I think they’ll be fine overall. The pitching is just too good, even if Max Fried and Cam Schlittler both choked this weekend (but “choked” in both cases meant “gave up three runs”).
If Weathers can even come CLOSE to how good he looked against Oakland, the rotation could soon be Cole, Fried, Schlittler, Rodon, and Weathers, with Gil and Warren in the minors (and one of them being trained to come back as a short man for the rest of the season).
They just need to weather this little storm, and, of course, get at least ONE MORE FUCKING GUY WHO COULD HIT.
Oh, and, of course, maybe PINCH HIT PAUL GOLDSCHMIDT IN THE NINTH INNING OF THE NEXT CLOSE GAME, YOU DICK!
McMahon’s game-ending first pitch groundout is the featured image.
Oddly enough, the Brewers ALSO started the season 8-2, and have ALSO lost five straight games. Weird.
In all fairness, you can hardly blame Boone’s wife.
Yeah. She married him because he had steady hands at third base, but he hasn’t played there in years.
Judge is a better player than he is a GM, manger, or hitting coach.
I wonder if PGold regrets coming here. He’s been horribly underutilized but we know Boone sucks. Tonight against Kikuchi I assume PGold starts. Will he sit Rice or let him catch. Why didn’t Rice catch all Spring?
is it possible that they are just so jinxed that whatever they try will fail anyway? even when they make sound decisions they barely work. From now on instead of pointing out that Cash and Boone are dumb maybe we should build the jinxed narrative until they are replaced.
“It’s not their fault, they’re just jinxed!”
“Can’t fix unlucky!”
NY Post “Shortstop Anthony Volpe, who has been on the injured list to start the season after undergoing elbow surgery last fall, will be meeting with team physician Dr. Christopher Ahmad later today. If all goes well, he may begin a rehab assignment as soon as tomorrow, in which he will test out changes to his swing designed to “keep…it on plane for a lot longer,” all in the hopes of recovering some of the offensive pop that made him one of the league’s top prospects before he made his Major League debut in 2023.”
The new changes like how they fixed MacMahon
They’ll need to prove themselves in a whole slew of cases to recover even the faintest whiff of confidence.
As of now, this evokes only a sarcastic smirk.
Martian thru 13 games 354/475/521 2/5 vs LHPs
Spence 233/344/471
Lombard 464/531/857
Veterans > youngsters.
I’d like to suggest we make Boone’s wife the manager.
Maybe Goldschmidt is already suffering an overuse injury?
Failed to mention a certain player at 133/528.
But elite defense
I didn’t mention Jazz, Wells or Cabby, either.
The only ones I singled out were McMahon, whose OPS+ is in the TEENS, and the still somehow hitless for the season Gricnuk and Escarra.
Judge should talk less and hit more is my opinion
I guess they’re afraid that if they let Rice catch he’ll be burned out by August. OTOH if he doesn’t get any PT behind the plate will he be hopeless when they need him to catch?
P Goldschmidt (R) 1B
A Judge (R) RF
C Bellinger (L) CF
G Stanton (R) DH
A Rosario (R) 3B
J Chisholm Jr. (L) 2B
R Grichuk (R) LF
J Caballero (R) SS
A Wells (L) C
Ha ha ha ha ha … Goldschmidt isn’t good enough to ever PH but IS good enough to lead off? Make that make sense.
Agree on Rice. You gotta keep his bat in the lineup at this point. Wells can play when he cools off.
Why do I bother even caring enough to comment, it’s Boone.
If Wells cooled off, he’d form a Bose-Einstein condensate.
LOL Veggie, had to look that one up. Of course, I meant Wells can play when Rice cools off. 😉
I think the plan is to use Escarra as much as they can early, to give Rice a break until Escarra is sent down when Volpe returns, at which point Rice will then become the backup catcher.
Cade cleared waivers And Hal pocketed $50K. Today, the Yankees returned Rule 5 Draft Pick RHP Cade Winquest to the St. Louis Cardinals.