December 21, 2024

24 thoughts on “Yankees (93-66) vs. Pirates (74-85) Friday, September 27, 2024, 7:05 PM EDT

  1. It’s rare I yearn for a negative outcome for a Yankee but I was doing it in that during that Verdugo at bat. The thought of Boone talking about how “We finally got him going,” next weekend is terrifying.

    1. I’m not closely following this, but what do you want teams to do when they are getting blown out by the Dodgers? walk Ohtani, but no one else? While at the same time complaining about teams walking Judge?

      The bigger question is why no one is holding a not particularly fast, but good base stealer on.

    2. When was the last time a team pitched to Judge with two on and first base open? Or most other top sluggers over the years? That is the point, teams keep pitching to Ohtani in spots that other top guys don’t get pitched to. I did mention the base stealing issue a while back.

    3. But if this were some MLB pressure/conspiracy, surely it would apply to Judge too, who is as nearly an electric talent and also playing for a massive market and internationally popular team.

  2. “what do you want teams to do when they are getting blown out by the Dodgers? walk Ohtani, but no one else? While at the same time complaining about teams walking Judge?”
    Clay, Brian… but Don is actually making perfect sense. Either it’s surprising that they’re NOT walking Ohtani in those situations, or it’s surprising that they ARE walking Judge in those situations. How can you argue that “OF COURSE they walk Judge, that’s only natural!”, but at the same time “WHY ON EARTH would they walk Ohtani, it makes no sense!” It can’t be both.
    The only real answer I can see is that there’s a pretty stark difference in the batters coming up BEHIND Judge and Ohtani. That’s at least some kind of answer, I guess.

    1. In other words:
      If he’s “complaining about teams walking Judge”, Ohtani being treated differently might reasonably annoy him.
      And if he’s complaining that they ARE giving Ohtani pitches to hit, he can reasonably be annoyed that they’re NOT giving Judge pitches to hit in those same situations.

    2. It’s PRECISELY that Ohtani bats in front of Betts, Freeman, and Smith, and Judge bats in front of Wells, Stanton and Jazz that it isn’t weird that they keep pitching to Ohtani.

      The Yankees have decided that protecting Soto is more important than protecting Judge, and since they lead the league in runs scored AND have seemingly kept Soto happy when they’re trying to get him to re-sign here, I think it makes sense.

    3. Yeah, that’s the argument, I think it’ll look much clearer to everyone that way.

      “and since they lead the league in runs scored AND have seemingly kept Soto happy when they’re trying to get him to re-sign here”<–and add the fact that Judge seems to have handled batting without protection… pretty… darned… well!

Leave a Reply