May 15, 2025

15 thoughts on “Yankees.com: Goldy thrives in a pinch, Judge clubs No. 15 to seal win

    1. On the other hand Matt Carpenter and going back a ways, David Justice and Glenallen Hill

    2. If we make a list of all the veterans cash bought here I think the bad far outweighs the good.
      Youkilis, Hafner, Vernon wells, etc

    3. I think he costs less than anyone mentioned in this thread. The Yankees paid $42m for Vernon Wells and $50m for Donaldson. Let that sink in.

      I think Cashman’s love for washed up vets is absurd most times, but Goldschmidt was a steal. He was 2 years removed from an MVP, 1 year from a 120 OPS+ season and his underlying numbers weren’t that far off his career averages.

      For a 1 year $12.5m deal, I’m surprised there wasn’t more competition.

    4. My concern with Goldschmidt is that the Yankees will think last year was a fluke and give him a 4 year 120M contract this winter and be regretting it within a year.
      Pat him on the back, let Rice/Bellinger play first and sign Tucker.

  1. Bellinger had a bad April but for May hes 286/348/452 which is a bit better than last year and in line with his carreer. If he can do that all year then it’s fine. But wow his April was terrible. 204/281/357. Putrid

    Same for Jasson who crushing it in May (273/359/606) vs April (228/317/369).
    If he’s as good as May he’s an all star. If he’s as good as April he’s a minor leaguer. Then again most of his May was from one game.

    1. It’s not Hyde’s fault that Mike Elias, despite having the okay from ownership to spend more, won’t

    2. They have a lot of young talent that isn’t showing up this season. Their pitching may not be great, but no excuse for being 15-27. The manager needs to go.

  2. wheelhouse: goldschmidt real? at minimum, seems like he can hang on for a while longer if a team is willing to soft-platoon him against tougher rhp

    Dan Szymborski: Eh, there’s a lotta BABIP in there. Even giving him a higher one from his history, there’s a lot of helium

Leave a Reply