July 18, 2026

18 thoughts on “Yankees.com: With bats providing cushion, Cole keeps building toward prime form

  1. Agree. And odd to call going from 2 starts with NOTHING allowed to a few starts that were good, but not superlative “building towards” anything.
    (I’m not in the least down on Cole, he’s fantastic, just to be clear.)

    1. Oh, totally. Cole seems to be comfortably sliding into that #2 slot in the rotation behind Schlittler, but I almost wonder if he would be their #3 if Fried returns healthy.

    2. Well, I hope Cole will be between the last two (pretty good) games and the first two (immaculate) games.
      And I’d trust him in a big postseason spot over Fried (who I really like, but still).

    3. Yeah, agreed, but I think that also determines just how well Fried pitches when he returns. But yes, in general, I imagine the plan will be Schlittler/Cole/Fried/Rodon. That’s a fucking sick rotation.

    4. Absolutely. I think Cole may end up back at #1, but – either way if Fried is your #3, you’re in pretty damned good shape.

    5. It’s a fascinating question whether you just trust Cole’s experience and make him the #1 regardless. I don’t HATE the idea, but Schlittler has been just so fucking dominant that it’s hard not to want him to be the guy who pitches the most games.

    6. Schlittler had a stretch of 5 or six really not so dominant games, actually. The last one looked better, although still not what he started the season with.
      And Cole came back with two untouchable outings. At that point, to me, he was clearly ahead of Schlittler.
      Right now, I think, it’s hard to say.

    1. Rays played on Monday when the Yankees were off. It should even up again tomorrow.

  2. As for playoff number 1 the answer right now has to be “we’ll see.” I would be tempted to say Cole based on experience, but Schlittler has also proved himself in the playoffs

    1. It’s moot, everyone will be injured. Clarke Schmidt will be the #1 followed by Gil, Yarby, and Blackburn, with Oswaldo Cabrera available in long relief

    2. Clay Holmes acquired in a deadline trade for Lombard, Dominguez, and Elmer

    3. Boone will make Holmes the closer because his stuff plays up in the ‘pen. Robertson will come out of retirement to be the setup guy

  3. Anthony Kay does have a huge split for the year

    P Goldschmidt (R) 1B
    B Rice (L) DH
    A Rosario (R) 3B
    C Bellinger (L) CF
    J Domínguez (S) RF
    J Chisholm Jr. (L) 2B
    J Caballero (R) LF
    A Volpe (R) SS
    A Sánchez (R) C

Leave a Reply