October 22, 2024

382 thoughts on “ALCS Game 5: Yankees (3-1) @ Guardians (1-3) Saturday, October 19, 2024, 8:08 PM EDT

    1. Yeah, this game is about starter length. Like I said yesterday, anyone getting <5 innings is going to have a rough game.

  1. I love that the announcers spent all game shouting about how Cole is all about emotion, how he wears his heart on his sleeve, and Rodon’s take is that he’s like a robot and showed zero emotion until his day was over.

    1. Yeah fine with the send. Gleyber’s stumble/delay got him, but it still took a crazy throw. And add the Yankees showed, they could not be relied on to get the runner in.

    2. Yes, exactly. But even then he’d have scored, if he’d just run hard all the way, which is the proof that it was a good send.

    3. A great play by a dude who has made many great plays with a great arm certainly enters into the equation. On the one hand you might gain a run. OTOH you might lose multiple runs. I don’t know exactly what the odds should be of scoring but I’m guessing it should be very high. It wasn’t a bang, bang play at the plate.
      Somebody run a simulation.

    1. What’s funny is that he did a great job, and yet you can see how he could easily do even BETTER, ya know? Sort of similar to Gil, who had a good outing in general, but there were so many places where he could have been better.

    1. How do they AVOID scoring in those innings? It’s mind-bending.
      Yes, that could easily happen.
      But I don’t think so. They’ve been getting more offense, not straight WOE.

  2. That play at the plate gave Bibee courage. I’m not big on team momentum, but when it comes to the pitcher, I’m a believer. IMO the plus minus was one sided.

    1. There have been a ton of them, and I don’t think they’ve been even close to being evenly distributed.
      But that probably has a lot to do with the very different hitting approaches of these two teams.

  3. I mean, whatever, I’ll definitely take him dominating the other guys if he struggles with Bo fucking Naylor, but it was still outrageous, especially since it took him ELEVEN FUCKING PITCHES to allow an RBI double to BO NAYLOR.

  4. This is why Trevino should NOT have been on the roster. And if by some luck they make the WS, Trevino better not be on the roster. Trevino can’t hit, and he is a liability behind the plate with his inability to throw runners out. At least Narvaez is solid defensively, and no one can possibly look worse at the plate than Wells has for 7-weeks.

    1. Agree. This way you can pinch hit for Wells or maybe even start Narvaez against a LHP. Even before Wells went south he was bad against LHPs.

    1. I think some of that was also on Verdugo not pulling off, and judge trying to avoid him

    1. Yeah bizarre. Rodon did what he was supposed to. And he’s still a better strikeout pitcher than leiter.

    1. Boone is punting just like Roberts did in game 5. No way the Yankees can lose 2 at home. HAHAHAH.

    1. It’s funny, he wouldn’t have pitched here if the Yankees hadn’t scored, so it’s kind of sort of a good thing that they gave up that second run. Kind of sort of.

  5. YES!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
    NO FUCKING STOPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPARLOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!

    1. He swung and missed and four pitches a foot off the plate tonight. Including to start the at bat. What in the literal fuck was that?!

    2. Seriously. I was just wondering how Stanton ever gets a hit street those two swings and how often he swings at breaking balls in the other batters box

    1. People strike out on fastballs all the time. But yes, I wouldn’t have pitched to him at all.
      Having said that, Stanton isn’t obligated to ONLY crush good pitches. He has every right to crush mistakes. That’s part of baseball, too, right?

  6. The Indians’ manager really has to answer for that. I know I’d have gone to that bullpen. And I know I’d never have pitched to Stanton there.
    But he did, and – wow!

    1. After the DP, you maybe go for it. But you tell Bibee, only fastballs way up and sliders down and way away

  7. Even more barrelled than the previous one. 117.
    So what if you’re supposed to hit it? Then you’d better hit it. And few can hit it like that.
    Be happy, folks.

  8. Clay, I’m puzzled by your take on the Stanton HR. Fine, he doesn’t hit much out of the strike zone… maybe, I’d be interested at looking at all the other postseason homers. But let’s say that’s true. The catcher set up outside the zone. The pitcher missed. That’s part of the game, right? And you still have to make use of the mistake, which players fail to do ALL THE TIME. I mean, why demean Stanton’s performance when it’s been nothing short of spectacular?

    1. Not Clay…and no one is taking away from Giancarlo for hitting that ball a ton. But he missed the spot by 30 inches. You just cannot throw a strike in that situation.

    2. I mean, it was a joke.

      Stanton had been great. And would absolutely win the MVP of the Yankees win this.

      But there was also no reason to throw anything hittable there.

    3. Well, no kidding. That’s what a mistake is.
      And it WAS just that, a mistake – the catcher set up outside the zone.

  9. How good much Wells be behind the plate to justify THIS?
    I mean, we’ve seen plenty of slumps. This is something else. It’s insane. How can anyone whose’s ever been good, let alone known for his hitting, be this pre-doomed in every at bat? It’s somewhere in that limbo between frightening and nauseating.

    1. Yeah. But they should really be pinch hitting for Wells in key situations. Put on the bunt sign when there’s a runner on 1st. Make him take pitches until 2 strikes.

  10. Classic Wells! Boone uses a pinch runner, but then doesn’t try to score with a pinch hitter, so now all you’ve accomplished is Rizzo’s bat out of the game. Good ol’ Boone.

  11. Cano set a postseason record with 29 straight hitless at-bats on his way to a 3-for-40 (.075) showing in the Yankees’ nine postseason games in 2012.

    Swisher was 091/473 in 2010 and 165 over 47 games for the Yankees.

    1. Especially since the technology shows (a) he was wrong, and (b) he’s not consistent with his previous calling.

    1. I was expecting Cousins, Mayza, Weaver tonight so … I’m not too surprised. He’s basically punting until the 9th.

    1. Encouraging. Especially if it goes 10 the Yankees are unlikely to score considering who’s coming up.

  12. YEEEEEEEEEEEEESSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS SSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS SSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS SSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS SSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS SSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS SSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS SSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS SSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS SSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS SSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS !

    SOTO!

    1. Doesn’t count. Just trying to even out the managerial column to make it a fair contest between the players.
      Still didn’t come close to Boone, though.

    1. Los Angeles has been described as interminable in a number of ways, including its sprawl …

    2. Yes, sure.
      But we’d better hope they prove ultimately to be terminable.
      For we mean to termine them!

    1. They were just as lucky with bloops and Yankee miscues.
      The Yankees genuinely had a few more moments of coming through.

  13. If only Judge can catch fire…
    _
    By the way, as Stanton was ON FIRE, I suggest our nickname for postseason Stanton should be the Towering Inferno.

    1. Anybody remember NoMaas? they had this hilarious graphic they made in 2009 of ARod, a Centaur with a flaming sword with the background being LAA’s stadium in flames. I feel like Stanton deserves the flaming sword meme treatment.

  14. I don’t want the Mets. NY against the Ex Pats for the 12th time is how it should be and Ka Ching for television. Get to watch a lot of Yankee Dodger highlights Cookie Lavagetto, Billy Martin, Podres, Don Larsen, Koufax, Reggie, Mick and The Duke

    1. I was surprised by how much cheering there was for Yankee moments. the stadium WAS loud after all the Guardians fans left.

    1. Extremely well-deserved. Monster series, 4 HR in 5 games. Wow!

      Another crazy stat on mlb.com: Stanton has 8 hits against Cleveland in the postseason all-time. All 8 are HRs. Next longest such streak (all hits are HRs) is 5 HRs (Thome vs Red Sox).

    1. I don’t know, you think Boone has the ability to get them to like each other?
      Could be, though. No reason his historical badness as an in-game manager and awful post-game press blather have to mean he’s not good at that. They clearly do really like him, despite all the harm he does them.

Leave a Reply