July 6, 2025

13 thoughts on “Yankees.com: ‘Another Judgie moment’ in dramatic 9th, but Yanks fall in chaotic 10th

    1. It’s BAFFLING. Boone made the argument that they were essentially embarrassed by how badly they fucked it up initially, and that were just trying to cover up their initial screwup.

    2. His first 2 years phenom was successful stealing at about an 80% rate. This year he’s at 58% which would make stealing seldom the right move. Are they on to his little hop?

  1. I get the feeling that neither Volpe nor Jazz have an understanding of when stealing is just not smart. I said at the time even if he were safe, it was a dumb play. This season phenom has 7 SBs, and 5 CSs. That’s terrible,is he telegraphing his timing?

    Meanwhile the townies are playing better, Bregman will be back soon and their prospects are here. They won 2/3 against us and the Rays.

    1. Yeah, even if he’s safe, they still need to drive him in AND hold Boston to less than one run. In a tie game in the BOTTOM of the 10th inning, you can at least make an ARGUMENT for it, but not there. It was just foolish, and Boone was defending it after the game, which was annoying. Just cop to the fuck-up, dude!

    2. He might well have been out, but it wasn’t conclusive, which makes the umpire’s decision just plain wrong.
      Having said that – yes, absolutely agree, just a dumb thing to try. (Unless they’re ignoring you and you have a HUGE jump, I guess.)

    3. His first 2 years phenom was successful stealing at about an 80% rate. This year he’s at 58% which would make stealing seldom the right move. Are they on to his little hop?

  2. It sure looked to me Volpe was safe. Did anyone see anything in the replay that was clear and obvious to lend credence to why they overturned the call

    1. The announcers said his fingers were up and the palm hadn’t hit the bag yet. I think that may be true, but you can’t SEE it, and that’s the very definition of “inconclusive.”

    2. The announcers said his fingers were up and the palm hadn’t hit the bag yet. I think that may be true, but you can’t SEE it, and that’s the very definition of “inconclusive.”

      It was a very weird decision by Volpe either way, though, right? Why slide like that?!

Leave a Reply